Guides

Why a Car Key Stops Working, and How to Tell Which Fault You Have

Nine times out of ten it is the battery, and that is a five minute fix. The useful part is the other one time, because a key that fails with a fresh battery in it is telling you something specific, and the symptom says which fault it is.

Written by Anthony Haley, auto locksmithUpdated 18 November 20267 minute read

Start by working out what still works

Before anything else, separate the three jobs a car key does. They fail independently, and knowing which one has stopped narrows the fault immediately.

  • The buttons send a radio signal to lock and unlock. These need the battery.
  • The blade turns the lock by hand. This needs nothing at all.
  • The chip tells the immobiliser the key is genuine, so the engine will run. This does not use the battery either, which surprises most people.

The three-question test. Does the blade open the driver door by hand? Does the car start when you hold the fob against the start button? Does a spare key behave the same way? Three answers will place almost any fault without a single tool.

The buttons do nothing, and the range had been shrinking

That is a flat battery, and it is the most common fault by a wide margin. Range drops before buttons stop entirely, so a fob that needed to be closer and closer over a few weeks has been warning you. Changing the cell is a job for the kitchen table and the method is set out in the car key battery guide.

New battery in, and still nothing

This is where most articles stop and where the real diagnosis starts. A fresh cell that changes nothing points inside the fob.

  • Corroded or broken contacts. The metal tabs holding the cell can tarnish or snap off the board, usually after a leak from an old battery or a trip through a washing machine. The fob looks perfect and is electrically dead.
  • A cracked solder joint. Years of being dropped works the joints loose. The symptoms give it away, because it works when squeezed in a certain way, or intermittently in the cold.
  • Worn button pads. The conductive pad under each rubber button wears through. One button stops, then another, while the rest keep working.
  • Water in the case. Rain or a wash cycle. It often works for a week or two afterwards and then fails for good as the corrosion spreads.

All four are repairs rather than replacements. The electronics inside a fob are mendable far more often than people assume, and the cost is a fraction of a new key.

The car unlocks but will not start

Now the fault has moved away from the buttons entirely, because unlocking proves the radio side is healthy. What has failed is the conversation between the chip and the immobiliser.

What you seeWhat it usually means
Dashboard shows an immobiliser or key symbol, engine turns over but does not fireThe chip is not being read. Either the chip has failed or the aerial ring around the ignition has.
Nothing at all when you press start, no crankMore often the car battery than the key. Check whether the interior lights are strong.
Starts with the spare but not the main keyThe main key has lost its programming or its chip has failed. A key problem, not a car problem.
Neither key starts itThe car side. The aerial ring, the immobiliser module or the wiring between them.

Try the spare before you spend anything. It is the single most useful diagnostic you own. If the spare starts the car, the fault is in one key and nothing is wrong with the vehicle.

The key will not turn in the ignition

A mechanical problem, and it divides cleanly by whether the steering wheel moves.

  • The wheel is locked solid and the key will not budge. Turn the wheel firmly left and right while gently turning the key. The steering lock is loaded against the pin and this releases it. This is normal and it is not a fault.
  • The key goes in but turns stiffly or not at all. A worn key, a worn barrel, or both. A key that has been copied from a copy loses shape at every generation, which is why an original or a key cut to the vehicle lasts longer.
  • The key turns part way and stops. Usually the barrel wafers rather than the key. This gets worse until it strands you, so it is worth dealing with early.
  • The key is stuck and will not come out. Make sure the car is fully in park and the steering is not loaded. Forcing it is how blades snap off inside the barrel.

Deciding between the key and the barrel matters because the repairs are different. A simple test is to try the spare. If the spare turns cleanly, the first key is worn. If both are stiff, the barrel is.

The fob works sometimes and not others

Intermittent faults have a short list of causes, and two of them are not the key at all.

  • Interference. Keys kept against a phone, near a laptop, or used in a car park under a transmitter can be drowned out. Step away a few metres and try again.
  • A weak cell on its way out. Works warm, fails cold. Coin cells lose voltage in low temperatures, which is why these faults appear in January.
  • A loose battery seat. The right cell in a slightly sprung holder makes and breaks contact as the fob moves in a pocket.
  • A dying receiver in the car. Rarer, and the tell is that both keys behave badly in the same way at the same time.

When it is worth paying somebody

Most of what is above costs nothing to try. The point of a diagnosis is knowing which problem you have before you spend, because the three outcomes are very differently priced.

DiagnosisRoughly what it means
BatteryA pound or two, done at home in five minutes.
Fob repairContacts, pads or a case. Far cheaper than a new key and keeps your existing programming.
New keyOnly when the chip or the key itself has genuinely failed, or there is no key left at all.

If the diagnosis points at a repair

Most keys that stop working are mended rather than replaced, and knowing which fault you have is what keeps the bill small. Send a photograph of the key and say what it does and does not do.

Describe the symptom and I will tell you which it is

A picture of the key and one line about what still works is usually enough to say whether you are looking at a battery, a repair or a new key. There is no charge for the answer.

Related guides and services
the types of car key explained, what a replacement key costs, car key programming, immobiliser reset and key deletion.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my car key fob not working even with a new battery?

The fault is inside the fob rather than in the cell. Broken contacts, a cracked solder joint, worn button pads or water damage account for nearly all of these, and every one of them is a repair rather than a replacement.

Can you drive with a dead key fob?

Yes, on almost every car. The emergency blade inside the fob opens the door by hand, and on a push-button car you hold the dead fob against the start button so the chip can be read without radio. The handbook shows where that spot is.

Why does my car unlock but not start?

Because unlocking and starting use different parts of the key. Unlocking is the radio side, which clearly works. Starting is the chip talking to the immobiliser, and that is what has failed.

My key will not turn in the ignition. Is the key or the car at fault?

Try the spare. If the spare turns cleanly, the first key is worn. If both are stiff, it is the barrel, and the barrel is what needs the work.

Does a key lose its programming on its own?

No. Programming is held in the car and in the chip, and neither forgets because a battery went flat. If a key suddenly stops being recognised, look at the chip, the aerial ring or the contacts rather than assuming the programming has gone.

One button works and the others do not. Is that fixable?

Yes. That is worn conductive pads under the rubber, and it is one of the most common fob repairs there is. It does not need a new key and it does not need reprogramming.

Should I just buy a replacement fob online?

Only with care. A fob bought online arrives uncut and unprogrammed, so it still needs both doing, and cheap ones often use a chip that the car will not accept. The saving is usually smaller than it looks once the cutting and coding are counted.

How do I know whether it is the key or the car?

The spare answers it. A spare that behaves normally means the car is fine and one key has failed. Two keys behaving identically badly points at the vehicle.

Scroll to Top