Guides
Keyless Car Theft, and What Actually Stops It
Relay theft works by carrying your key signal from inside the house to the car on the drive. It takes two people, about sixty seconds, and leaves no damage. The defences that work are the ones that stop the signal leaving the house, or stop the car moving once it starts.
How relay theft actually works
A proximity key is awake. It is listening for the car and answering when the car calls, which is what lets you unlock by touching the handle. That conversation is short range by design, and relay theft defeats it by making the range longer.
One device finds the key
Somebody stands close to the house, usually at the front door or a window, with a receiver that picks up the weak signal your key is giving off indoors.
The signal is relayed
That receiver passes the signal to a second device held by somebody standing at the car, which rebroadcasts it as though the key were in their hand.
The car believes the key is present
It unlocks, and the start button works, because every check the car makes has been answered correctly.
It drives away
No glass broken, no lock forced and nothing on the car to show what happened.
Nothing is hacked and nothing is cloned. That matters, because it tells you where the defence has to go. The system is not being broken. It is being extended. Stop the signal travelling and the whole method fails.
What works
Three things genuinely interrupt the chain, and they work at different points in it.
| Defence | What it stops | Honest assessment |
|---|---|---|
| A signal blocking pouch or tin | The key being heard from outside the house | The cheapest and most effective single step. It only works if the key goes in it every time, including the spare. |
| Distance from doors and windows | The signal reaching the street at usable strength | Free. A hallway hook by the front door is the worst place in the house for a key, and most people use one. |
| A sleep function on the key | The key transmitting while it is still | Built into some makes. Worth asking the dealer whether yours has one and how to turn it on. |
| A mechanical lock on the wheel or pedals | The car being driven even after it starts | Unfashionable, visible and effective. A thief looking for a sixty second job moves on. |
| Blocking access to the diagnostic port | A new key being programmed at the kerb | Relevant to a different attack, where a thief gets into the car and codes a fresh key rather than relaying yours. |
Test the pouch rather than trusting it. Put the key in, close it, and walk up to the car. If the doors unlock, the pouch is not working and it is worth knowing that on your own driveway rather than afterwards.
What does not work
- A fridge, a microwave or a biscuit tin. Some block, many do not, and none of them is designed to. A tin with a loose lid is a tin with a gap.
- Taking the battery out. It stops the radio and it stops you using the car normally, and most people stop doing it within a week.
- Parking nose in. It makes no difference to a relay attack at all.
- Assuming an older car is safe. Older cars are not relay targets, but they are easier to take in other ways. Different risk, not no risk.
Where the spare key sits
This is the part most advice misses. Households protect the key in daily use and leave the spare in a kitchen drawer, which is often closer to an outside wall than the first key ever gets.
Both keys need the same treatment, and that is also the argument for knowing where your spare actually is. If you cannot put your hand on it today, you are relying on one key and the theft question is not your only problem.
If it has already happened
- Report it to the police and get a crime reference. The insurer will want it and so will the DVLA if the vehicle is recovered.
- Tell your insurer quickly. Relay theft claims are sometimes queried precisely because there is no damage, and a prompt report with the detail fresh is worth having.
- If the car is recovered, treat the keys as compromised. Any key that was used or copied during the theft should be deleted from the vehicle so it cannot start it again. Cutting a new key does not disable an old one.
The honest summary
A pouch used consistently, keys kept away from the front of the house, both keys treated the same way, and something mechanical for a car that sits on a driveway overnight. That combination defeats the overwhelming majority of relay attempts, and none of it is expensive.
What it will not do is make a car impossible to steal. The goal is not perfection. It is being a slower target than the next car on the street, because the method depends entirely on being quick.
After a theft or an attempt
The part of this that is a locksmith job rather than a security product is the keys themselves. Deleting a key that may have been copied, and getting a second key back into the household, are both done at the vehicle.
If a key may have been copied
Tell me the make, model and year and what happened. Deleting a compromised key from the car is a same-visit job and it is the step that actually closes the door.
Related guides and services
the types of car key explained, car key battery replacement, spare car keys, car key replacement.
Frequently asked questions
Can keyless cars be stolen without the key?
Yes, by relaying the signal from your real key rather than by defeating it. The car is answered correctly at every step, which is why there is no damage.
Does a faraday pouch actually work?
Yes, when it is intact and the key goes in it every time. Test yours by putting the key inside, closing it fully and walking up to the car. If the doors respond, the pouch has failed.
Is a biscuit tin as good as a pouch?
No. A sealed metal container can block the signal, but tins are not designed to and a loose lid leaves a gap. If you use one, test it the same way you would test a pouch.
Should I keep my keys upstairs?
It helps, because distance and walls both weaken the signal. The important part is away from the front door, the letterbox and ground floor windows, which is exactly where most key hooks are.
Does my spare key need protecting too?
Yes. A spare in a kitchen drawer is often nearer an outside wall than the key you carry. Both keys need the same treatment.
Will a steering lock stop relay theft?
It does not stop the car starting, and it does stop it being driven away quickly, which is the whole business model. A visible mechanical lock is a strong deterrent precisely because it is visible.
Can my car be given a new key by a thief?
That is a separate attack from relay theft. It needs access to the inside of the car and the diagnostic port. It is also why deleting old keys matters after any break in.
My car was stolen and recovered. Are my keys still safe to use?
Treat them as compromised. Any key that may have been copied should be deleted from the vehicle, and that is a separate job from cutting a new one.